• 1 Post
  • 12 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 18th, 2023

help-circle
  • You could get similar (and in some ways faster as routing is better with fast single cores) performance with an X10SLL-F, Xeon E3-1271V3, 16GB of RAM and an Intel X520 10G NIC.

    Power draw will be higher with a maximum around 110 watts vs 55 for the DEC 850 v2 but that is only under full load, the real world load will be around 45 watts vs 30 watts.

    You can easily increase the ram in the Supermicro motherboard, as well as put in multiple 10G NIC’s or even faster. Throw a couple mirrored SSD’s (the Intel D3-S4510’s are amazing) and drop it into a case with a psu and you can be up and running for around 300 to 400 through eBay, the mobo and cpu is running 80 bucks together.

    NVME drive in a router isn’t worth much, outside of boot time and logs it just sits there. Even a HDD is fine for that, a SATA SSD will boot in about 30 seconds after POST. I’m using the X10SLL-F with an E3-1226 v3, 16GB of RAM, and a pair of D3-S4510’s that are underprovioned. I do not have native IPv6 and use a Wireguard tunnel to Route64, multiple vLAN’s, run CrowdSec with Intrusion Detection and UnboundDNS beyond the base system on a 1Gbps fiber connection WAN with 10Gbps fiber backbone LAN.

    OpnSense is truthfully meant to be managed through the GUI or the API. If you want to control through a CLI you may find building a system on FreeBSD with packages is better. The tools used are mostly things in the FreeBSD pkg system and can be recreated, the OpnSense setup is mainly a GUI, an API, and some middleware that makes everything work. I’ve been using OpnSense since 15.7, I tried multiple others before then including running Openwrt on a WRT54G IMHO the DEC850 is way overpriced so unless you are running this for a business you will probably be better suited with some used server hardware


  • I’m a bare metal guy when it comes to routers.

    With that said you are fretting over something that probably won’t matter and that is the ethernet port speed. Your current router only has gigabit ports and the router can only pass data from the LAN to the WAN at speeds fast enough to saturate your internet connection speeds. The only advantage of 2.5gbps on the router would be IF you are running multiple vLAN’s. Since you are already using the router as a point for your switch to connect to the internet you are already limited to 1Gbps speeds.

    Install OpnSense on the device you have available, set it up for the basics (DHCP reservations, IP addresses for the LAN, etc.), change the ip address in the original router to something that will work with your new setup and turn off the DHCP server. Then do some testing with your new router and see what you think. The old router will work as an ok access point and switch for now, grab a cheap switch to expand if you need to since the WAN port on the archer will no longer be usable.

    Later on when you have some extra cash you can grow and expand where you feel the need. I’m using 10Gbps for my backbone with 1Gbps Dell 5548 PowerConnect switches for the majority of devices. You can get the PowerConnect switches on ebay for around 50 to 100 bucks easily. Most clients don’t need more than 1Gbps (even 4k cameras) and a 10Gbps card dropped in your server will give you great speeds for cheap. An Intel X520 10G NIC can be picked up for 30 bucks add a couple sfp+ modules for about 10 each plus an OM3 fiber cable for a few bucks and you are set for a while. If you get a Dell PowerConnect 5548P (the P makes it a POE switch) and you can power POE cameras and POE access points without anything extra and still use the rest of they’re ports for regular computer connections.








  • No clue. Don’t use it myself. I am able to access the website so I would assume the rest is up and working.

    Your ISP may be blocking access (many ISP’s do not allow hosting things on home connections so check your TOS.) Why they would block access to the website I have no clue but they could see allowing it as allowing people to host a service.

    Disconnect your phone from wifi and see if you can access DuckDNS. You can also do some troubleshooting and testing https://www.golinuxcloud.com/how-to-check-if-isp-is-blocking-website/

    Also depending on your router if you can setup DNS over TLS or DNS over HTTPS and use two different DNS providers not controlled by your ISP.

    If you’re using an ISP provided Modem/Router you should probably consider setting up a proper firewall router and get just a modem or put the modem/router in bridge mode so you don’t double NAT.


  • Software RAID, yes. Hardware RAID, NOOOOOOOO!!!

    Without knowing what the hardware is in the system I need to stress that before getting started.

    Software RAID is controller independent, if the MoBo dies tonight you can get a replacement of whatever that is cheap or even grab a HBA (Host Bus Adapter) and hook the drives up. Hardware RAID requires an identical controller with the same version of firmware in most cases. In a home environment hardware RAID is a major pain, most corporations have spare hardware on hand if there is a failure so it’s not as much of an issue. Also JBOD (Just a Big Old Drive) is not the same as a HBA so using a hardware RAID controller with that turned on for a software RAID is asking for issues. For software RAID in OMV you will be looking at something like BTRFS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Btrfs or using a plugin to add ZFS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZFS

    I come from a FreeNAS/TrueNAS background using ZFS and SAS2008/SAS3008 HBA’s.

    There are different version of RAID array’s, you need to look them up and decide what works best for your data. What works for me or anyone else is irrelevant. No RAID is not a substitute for good backup policies, but it saves a potential TON of work doing a restore and the headaches associated with it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_RAID_levels

    RAID 0 or Mirrors is great for data integrity. You could put all 7 disks in a RAID 0 or mirror configuration and it would take 7 disk failures to lose your data.

    RAID 1 or Stripes is great for speed and storage capacity, the data is split into chunks and with all 7 disks you would have maximum capacity of the total sum of all the disks, one disk fails and all your data is gone like a fart in the wind.

    RAID 0+1 or Striped Mirrors combines the two above concepts. In some ways you get two disk failure and in others you don’t. Take 4 decks of cards, set two side by side, those are your mirrors. Take the other two and put them above the other pair, those are the stripes. Lose two mirrors and the data is gone, lose a single mirror in each stripe and the data is safe. You can mirror and stripe to your hearts content, want 3 mirrors with two stripes it takes 6 drives.

    RAID 5 or RaidZ 1 gives you one disk failure redundancy, how it functions depends on the raid controller or software utilized but basically data is split in to chunks and you have the ability to replace a single disk and fully recover. If a second disk fails your data is gone again. Some people consider this dead as the odds of a large drive having an issue during a rebuild is higher. https://www.servnetuk.com/insights/ure-is-raid-5-dead

    RAID 6 or RaidZ 2 adds a second disk failure redundancy. If you want maximum space this is what you should probably use with failure redundancy. It’s not super fast but unless you need the speed for anything in particular it’s a good trade off. With 7 drives this is a good option.

    RaidZ 3 Adds a third disk failure redundancy. This is what I use for most of my pools. When rebuilding you are stressing the disks to the maximum and that is when you will find a second issue pop up. In a RaidZ1 your data is gone, in a RaidZ2 you lost your last spare. In a RaidZ3 you still have one failure that will save your bacon.

    I have multiple pools. I have the majority of my regular data on a RaidZ3. I have a couple striped mirrors for things like VM’s, Docker containers, and things I want a little more speed on.

    You can also do things like RAID 0+5 or 1+5. In ZFS this would be called RaidZ1 with two vDev’s.

    I use TrueNAS because of ZFS, BTRFS is still a work in progress in comparison.

    I imagine about now you just about had your head explode, it’s tough to make this decision because it puts you down a path. I started when BTRFS was an infant, I stick with ZFS/TrueNAS because I know how things work and it suits my needs. You need to decide what will work for you and you may find that OMV isn’t the best path going forward. Take the time to really make a decision about what your needs are today and what they will be in the future 5 to 10 years plus down the road. Don’t just say, well (random person on the internet) says this is best so it’s what I will do. Every decision is about tradeoffs and compromises.

    Once you make a decision one of the best things you can do is do a burn in on the drives. I do it with BadBlocks and run smart tests. I just got done with a batch of 8TB SAS drives and found 4 with issues that were replaced before I even put them in to production. If a drive survives a torture test early on it’s less likely to have issues later on. I upgraded from a pool of 4TB drives and out of 11 drives I had 1 failure. When you get to the point where you are thinking about expanding your pool with new drives you will want to buy from a couple different sellers, at different times a week or two apart, or different manufacturer’s.

    One other thing I will add… Toshiba is verboten in my world. They don’t replace, they give you a check and you have to buy at current prices and it’s more of a PITA than I want to deal with. BackBlaze is also a great place for information about drive reliability. https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-storage/resources/hard-drive-test-data


  • No problem.

    Be sure to set a cron job for updating the DNS Blocklists, running zcrubs, smart tests, and trim if you are using a ssd.

    I am working on a way to do snapshots for the system as well for super simple restores that are automatically created. Before an update you WILL want to have a snapshot available. Once snapshots are automated I will probably start doing automatic updates. It basically creates a system similar to how an immutable OS works, if something goofs you can simply roll back to a previous working state and pause updates. I previously had a script I setup via a cron job but the system removed the job during an update.