• 1 Post
  • 5 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 28th, 2023

help-circle

  • Sure, of course it’s all fiction. LLMs didn’t exist as a concept when TNG was being written, so of course they didn’t write them to do that. Data was also an AI, and the holodeck was able to create a Moriarty so intelligent that he became self-aware and avoided deletion.

    My point is that modern LLMs are an approximation of intelligence that permit contemporary computers to respond to novel stimuli in a way that seems like intelligence. The computer on the show was far more advanced because it was fictional and set in the distant future. They never bothered to explain how it works, but there was nothing approximate about the intelligence it created in the holodeck.


  • It doesn’t. An LLM uses modeling to approximate the shape of a question and generate a novel answer within the parameters. It’s like a shortcut to actually knowing everything and providing authoritative answers.

    Sort of like the Scrabble champion who won in Spanish and French despite not knowing those languages. He simply learned patterns of words he could build with letters, but he didn’t know the meaning of any of the words.

    The holodeck ostensibly has access to all of federation knowledge and history, and when it has to generate novel information (like what would Einstein say to Newton while playing poker) then it extrapolates that informtation based on the sum total of existing information. The holodeck computer has a thorough understanding of the question, the parameters, and the answers (holograms) it creates. It isn’t abstracting the question or approximating the shape of the answer.



  • Ok, I like coffee, and I like cotton candy, and this is cute, so I almost hate to criticize it.

    But isn’t the cup just going to get all sticky? The bigger the cup, the quicker it will cool, and the more coffee you’ll need to fill it. You’ll only get a few “raindrops” of sugar before the steam stops coming off the cup. That’s barely any sugar, especially for a large cup. What do you do with the rest of the cloud? Are you supposed to smoosh the rest into your cup? Because that seems like too much sugar. Or do you share the cloud with people at your table?

    I think this concept would be better actualized as part of a dessert. Maybe like a hot peach cobbler or a sticky toffee pudding. Something that stays steaming for a minute, and you want to wait for it to cool, and it won’t need sugar but the little drops of sweetness won’t make it too sweet.